A handwritten letter on dragonfly stationary arrives in our mailbox.
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.
The First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America
I met Carla and Martin at a local café, a neutral space, not to interview them but to get to know them and then decide if I wanted to interview them formally for an article. Carla was concerned about her anonymity so there is therefore no possibility I'd write anything about her or Martin for the local paper, I told her, which is why I am writing this blog post instead. The request to remain anonymous came at the end of our visit together, and though I was disappointed, I understood. I don't post anonymous comments on my blog, and I don't quote anonymous sources because they cannot be verified, but for my blog, which is private, I hope that my readers trust that the encounter reported here happened. Be advised that names have been changed to protect Carla and Martin's identity.
I've met most of the clergy in New Paltz over the years; they have public personas. And they are active and outspoken. The Jehovah's Witnesses do not have clergy—they are more like the Quakers in their practice—but they have a "congregation" in New Paltz, and I sometimes see them on the street selling Bibles and pamphlets. And even though a Witness or two has sometimes knocked on our door, I was surprised when a handwritten letter from Carla addressed to my husband & "Current Resident" arrived in our mailbox. The writing was meticulous, as carefully rendered as that of a 6th grader practicing her penmanship. The letter is signed: "Sincerely, Carla," with a phone number, and there was also a return address—Carla and Martin, with their last name—on the envelope.
When Mormons and Jehovah's Witnesses arrive at our door, they are usually in a small group, for their safety is my thinking. But we have never received a letter with an address and phone number. My parental instinct kicked in and I called Carla. At first she was puzzled when I thanked her for the letter—where did she get that gorgeous dragonfly stationary I asked her—and then thanked her for the Bible verses—and then told her I was calling because I was concerned for her safety. There was a long pause before she said, "It's very kind of you to call." Her voice was light, a young person's voice. I told her I am a journalist and would she and her husband like to meet for a coffee? To my surprise, or perhaps not, as they were probably still hoping to proselytize, they agreed. So I made it clear that I am secular, that I read the Bible as literature and history, but not to sustain a religious practice.
I arrived at the café early and took my favorite round table. Carla had texted a photo so I recognized them immediately. Martin is Black, Carla white which interested me right away. Where had they met? Had they been born into the faith? Carla had, Martin hadn't. Carla's mother is Jewish and was baptized. I asked them lots of questions and wondered if they vote—they do not—or if they follow the news—we are at war, after all, and Martin mumbled the word "Iran," but nothing else. I had read that about 9,000 Jehovah's Witnesses had been killed in the Holocaust because they refused to fight for the Wehrmacht; they were conscientious objectors. Were they aware, did they understand that the Nazis were about to decimate their people? Obviously not, or perhaps I shouldn't say that as the Jews were in denial, or ignorant of the Nazi genocidal intent also, or hadn't read Mein Kampf.
So there lay my curiosity. These deeply observant, calm and sweet natured young people were also descendants of a persecuted tribe. Is there any religion that has not been persecuted at one time or another in the long troubled history of mankind? Of course, persecution is not exactly genocide, not yet anyway.
Martin perked up when I asked about his background and his enthusiasm for Biblical verses. He hasn't had much education, whereas Carla is well educated. Still, she spends her days working in a Bible factory and her spare time writing letters and otherwise proselytizing. Before he got married to Carla, Martin had been to Italy on a mission, and fell in love with the country and its people and the food. Yes, he enjoys Bible study every day, several hours a day. "What Bible or Bibles do you read?" I asked "All of them," he replied, "and I especially like the Greek Bible."
"Oh, so you are a scholar," I said, ever the educator encouraging young people to get as much education as possible. I think Martin understood. I hope he and and Carla find their way out of the sect—some would call it a cult—that has captivated and captured them, a sect that my research tells me does not welcome gay "sinners." What if I had told them that I was gay? But of course, I couldn't, because it would have been a lie, and that is a sin. My wish that they continue to educate themselves, and to vote, and to pay attention to the news can be construed as a judgment and, if so, I apologize. Carla and Martin's peaceful existence in this small town in the Hudson River Valley, the freedom to believe, the freedom to proselytize, is testament to the importance and rigor of the First Amendment.